Federal Court Strikes Down FTC’s Non-Compete Rule What It Means for Employers

Federal Court Strikes Down FTC’s Non-Compete Rule
What It Means for Employers

In a surprising turn of events, a federal court in Texas has struck down the Federal Trade Commission’s (FTC) non-compete rule, just days before it was set to take effect on September 4, 2024. This ruling has sent shockwaves through the employment law community, as it effectively halts the enforcement of the much-debated regulation that aimed to curtail non-compete agreements nationwide.

The Court’s Decision: A Blow to the FTC’s Authority

On August 20, 2024, the Northern District of Texas issued a decisive ruling against the FTC, determining that the agency exceeded its authority in attempting to promulgate the non-compete rule. The court found that while the FTC has substantive rule-making power in matters of deceptive acts and practices, it does not possess the same authority concerning unfair methods of competition, which was the basis for this rule.

The court also criticized the FTC’s approach, labeling the rule as “arbitrary and capricious.” According to the ruling, the FTC’s rule was founded on inconsistent and flawed empirical evidence, failed to consider the positive aspects of non-compete agreements, and disregarded substantial evidence supporting these agreements.

As a result, the court concluded that the FTC’s promulgation of the non-compete rule was an unlawful agency action, effectively nullifying the rule on a nationwide basis. This ruling means that the non-compete rule will not be enforced on its intended effective date or at any point thereafter unless an appeal overturns this decision.

What This Means for Employers

For employers, this ruling brings a significant sigh of relief. The impending non-compete rule had left many businesses scrambling to understand and comply with the new regulations. With the court’s decision, employers are no longer required to make immediate changes to their non-compete agreements at the federal level.

However, it is crucial to note that this ruling only impacts federal law. Employers must still navigate the complex landscape of state and local regulations regarding non-compete agreements. Several states have already enacted laws that limit or outright ban non-compete clauses, and these laws remain in full effect despite the federal court’s ruling.

As the trend against non-compete agreements continues at the state level, employers should remain vigilant. It may be prudent to consider alternative approaches, such as narrowly tailored non-solicitation agreements, to protect legitimate business interests like confidential information, trade secrets, and customer relationships.

Looking Ahead: Potential for Appeal and Broader Implications

While the court’s ruling is a significant development, it may not be the final word on the matter. The FTC has yet to issue a statement regarding its plans, but an appeal to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals is possible. However, given the conservative leanings of the Fifth Circuit, the likelihood of overturning the lower court’s decision appears slim.

Furthermore, with the 2024 presidential election on the horizon, changes in administration could influence the FTC’s priorities and the future of non-compete regulation.

In the meantime, employers should continue to monitor developments in this area and ensure compliance with applicable state and local laws. The striking down of the FTC’s rule does not eliminate the growing scrutiny of non-compete agreements across the United States.

Information contained in this Memo is intended for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or opinion, nor is it a substitute for the professional judgment of an attorney.  It is likely considered advertising.  Epps & Coulson, LLP encourages you to call to discuss these matters as they apply to you or your business.  Epps & Coulson, LLP’s dedicated professionals are available to help you navigate all your employment, business and real estate matters:  dawn@eppscoulson.com.

Epps & Coulson, LLP attorneys are admitted to practice in California, New York, Colorado, Texas and Oregon, staff licensed in France and affiliated Counsel offices in New York and Connecticut with lawyers also admitted in Connecticut, District of Columbia Massachusetts (pending), New Jersey, Hawaii, European Union, England and Whales, France (Paris Bar) and Sweden.

EPPS & COULSON, LLP
www.eppscoulson.com
www.companiescounsel.com